An air conditioner supplier scorecard rates every supplier on the same ten criteria, using weights that reflect your business, so quotes are compared on evidence instead of price. Score each criterion from 1 to 5, multiply by its weight, and total the result. Drop any supplier that scores below 3 on factory proof or quality, whatever the total says.
Most importers compare suppliers in a spreadsheet of unit prices. That works until a cheap quote hides a missing certificate or a thin warranty. A scorecard keeps those risks in view.Jede Probe gegen dieprüfliste für die genehmigung von mustern vor der produktionund feed-zitatdaten von einemRFQ-Vorlagein die gleiche scorecard.
The 10 Criteria
The ten criteria map to the twelve checks in our 12-point evaluation framework. Checks 1, 2, and 12 are merged into one criterion so the sheet stays short enough to use.
# | Criterion | Evidence to attach |
|---|---|---|
1 | Factory proof and transparency | Business license, factory address, video tour, audit report |
2 | Quality system and testing | ISO 9001 certificate, per-unit test records |
3 | Components | Compressor brand and model per unit |
4 | Certifications for your market | Certificates and test reports in the seller's name |
5 | Specification and rated performance | Spec sheet, rated test data, standard used |
6 | MOQ and flexibility | MOQ per model, mixing policy |
7 | Lead time and sampling | Sample timeline, written completion date |
8 | Landed cost transparency | Itemized quote on a stated Incoterm |
9 | Payment and contract terms | Draft contract, payment milestones |
10 | Warranty and after-sales | Written warranty, claims process, spare parts terms |
How to Score Each Criterion From 1 to 5
Scores need anchors, or two people will rate the same supplier differently. Use the rubric below. Scores of 2 and 4 sit between the anchors.
Criterion | 1 (weak) | 3 (acceptable) | 5 (strong) |
|---|---|---|---|
Factory proof | No address, no license | Address and license, no tour | Matching documents, live tour, shared audit |
Quality system | No certificate or records | ISO 9001, no unit records | ISO 9001 plus per-unit records by serial number |
Components | Brand unnamed | Brand named per range | Brand and model named per unit |
Certifications | Holder differs from seller | Certificates exist, models partly covered | Holder matches, exact models covered, current |
Specification | "Up to" figures only | Rated data without standard cited | Rated data under your market's standard |
MOQ | Changes between emails | Stated for some models | Stated per model, mixing rule in writing |
Lead time | Verbal estimate | Written range | Written date tied to order confirmation |
Landed cost | Unit price only | Freight included | Itemized on one Incoterm with exclusions listed |
Payment terms | Full payment upfront | Deposit and balance, no milestones | Milestone-based, payee matches certificate holder |
Warranty | Unwritten | Written, unit only | Written by component, claims process defined |
Weighting the Criteria for Your Business
Weights are where your own risk shows up. The two sets below total 100 and are examples, not rules.
Criterion | Distributor | Project buyer |
|---|---|---|
1 Factory proof | 12 | 10 |
2 Quality system | 12 | 10 |
3 Components | 10 | 8 |
4 Certifications | 14 | 18 |
5 Specification | 8 | 10 |
6 MOQ | 8 | 5 |
7 Lead time | 8 | 10 |
8 Landed cost | 10 | 10 |
9 Payment terms | 6 | 6 |
10 Warranty | 12 | 13 |
A distributor lives on resale margin and after-sales cost, so quality and warranty carry weight. A project buyer answers to a tender specification and a delivery date, so certifications and lead time weigh more. Change the numbers, but fix them before you look at quotes. Adjusting weights after seeing prices defeats the purpose.
A Worked Example With Two Hypothetical Suppliers
The numbers below are illustrative, not real suppliers. They use the distributor weights.
Criterion | Weight | Supplier A | Supplier B |
|---|---|---|---|
1 Factory proof | 12 | 5 | 2 |
2 Quality system | 12 | 4 | 2 |
3 Components | 10 | 4 | 2 |
4 Certifications | 14 | 5 | 3 |
5 Specification | 8 | 4 | 3 |
6 MOQ | 8 | 3 | 5 |
7 Lead time | 8 | 4 | 4 |
8 Landed cost | 10 | 3 | 5 |
9 Payment terms | 6 | 4 | 3 |
10 Warranty | 12 | 4 | 2 |
Weighted total (out of 5) | 4.08 | 2.98 |
Supplier B wins on MOQ and cost, which is why it looked attractive. It also scores 2 on factory proof and quality, so the gate removes it before the total matters. Supplier A costs more and requires larger orders, and the scorecard shows exactly what the extra money buys.
Gate Rules: When the Total Does Not Matter
Totals can hide a fatal weakness, so set two gates before you score.
Any score below 3 on criterion 1 or 2 removes the supplier. These two criteria decide whether the supplier is a real producer with a working quality system, and no price compensates for either.
Separately, a certificate holder that differs from the seller is a stop sign for the market in question, whatever its score. Our list of warning signs importers often miss covers others like it.
How to Run the Scorecard in Practice
Collect evidence first, then score. Fill the third column of the criteria table with documents before you assign a single number. If you cannot attach evidence, the score is a 1 or a 2.
Have two people score independently and compare. Disagreements usually point to a missing document. Date the sheet, because certificates expire and terms change.
For wording that produces scoreable answers, use the 15 questions to ask a manufacturer. To decide whether a supplier is a factory or a middleman before you score criterion 1, read how to tell a manufacturer from a trading company.
Scoring Mistakes That Skew the Result
Four errors account for most bad scorecards.
Scoring promises instead of documents. A supplier who says certificates are "available" has shown nothing yet. Score what you hold, not what you were told you can have.
Letting price leak into other criteria. A cheap quote tends to make everything else look better. Score the price only under landed cost, and score each remaining criterion as if the price were unknown.
Averaging away a gate failure. A 4.1 total with a 2 on factory proof is still a failed supplier. Apply the gates first, then total the scores.
Comparing different models. If Supplier A quotes a 12K inverter unit and Supplier B quotes a 12K fixed-speed unit, the specification and cost scores measure different products. Quote the same model type from every supplier before you compare.
Adjusting the Scorecard for Different Orders
The ten criteria suit most split and multi-split orders. A few cases need a change.
For OEM private-label orders, add an eleventh criterion for packaging, artwork approval, and label compliance, and cut the weight of MOQ if you plan large runs. For light commercial or cassette projects, add engineering support, such as drawings and installation documents. For a trial order, raise the weights on sampling and MOQ, since your first goal is learning the supplier cheaply.
Keep the total at 100 whatever you add, and record why the weights changed.
What a Scorecard Cannot Do
A scorecard organizes judgment. It does not replace it. A well-documented supplier can still deliver a bad batch, and a thin paper trail can hide a good factory with poor English.
Treat the result as a shortlist tool. Use it to decide who gets a sample, then let the sample and a first inspected order confirm the score. Rules and certificate requirements also change, so check current requirements for your market with your customs broker.
Building Your Own Air Conditioner Supplier Scorecard
Copy the criteria table, set your weights before you see quotes, attach evidence, and score with a second reviewer. Run it again after the first order, because delivery and claims handling tell you more than any sales call.
If you want a supplier to test it on, review iClimaAir, which publishes certifications, quality testing, and an OEM and OBM sourcing route, or check the certification documents by market it lists. For the certificate side, verify US listings in the AHRI directory and read what ISO 9001 does and does not certify.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What should an air conditioner supplier scorecard include? A: Include factory proof, quality system, components, certifications, specification, MOQ, lead time, landed cost, payment terms, and warranty. Add an evidence column for each, a 1-to-5 scoring rule, and weights that match your business, such as distributor or project buyer, plus gate rules.
Q: How do I weight the criteria? A: Weight them by the risk you carry. Distributors usually weight quality and warranty more because after-sales cost hits margin. Project buyers weight certifications and lead time more because tenders and schedules are fixed. Set the weights before you see any quotes.
Q: How often should I re-score suppliers? A: Re-score after the first order and then at least once a year, or whenever certificates, prices, or terms change. Delivery, defect handling, and claims response give you better data than the first sales conversation ever did.
Q: Can a scorecard replace a factory audit? A: No. A scorecard ranks the paperwork and answers you have collected, while an audit or pre-shipment inspection checks what actually happens on the line. Use the scorecard to pick who to audit, then use the audit to confirm or correct the scores.